In March 2026, Closter changed its zoning so townhouses and apartments can be built at the Closter Commons shopping center on Piermont Road and in the District 4B office area. On paper, the borough's housing plan counts room for hundreds of new homes on that land. In practice, nobody has filed a plan to build one. If you're comparing Northern Valley towns and hoping new townhouse construction will widen your options in Closter, the zoning map gives you less than it seems.
The gap comes from why the rezoning happened, who owns the land, and what the rules ask a builder to assemble. Read together, the documents show the gap between zoning for new homes and projects proposed in Closter.
A town with no vacant land had to point somewhere
The rezoning started with New Jersey's fourth round of affordable housing obligations, which covers 2025 to 2035. A Superior Court order fixed Closter's prospective need at 241 affordable units. The borough's Round 4 Housing Element and Fair Share Plan then calculated that Closter's realistic development potential is zero units. The plan puts it plainly: "Closter is a developed community with no vacant land," and future growth "will predominantly be limited to its existing commercial and industrial areas."
With zero buildable vacant land, all 241 units became "unmet need." State law then required the borough to zone sites likely to redevelop for at least 25 percent of that number, which works out to 61 affordable units. Closter's answer was overlay zoning on land that already holds stores and offices, with potential for 86 affordable units.
That's the starting point for everything that follows. The borough didn't choose these sites because a builder showed up wanting them. It chose them because the state required some site to carry the obligation, and commercial land was the only kind available.
What Ordinance 2026:1383 actually allows
The borough introduced Ordinance 2026:1383 on February 25, 2026 and adopted it on March 11. It moved Closter Commons, Block 1607, Lots 3 and 3.01 through 3.33, into the District 3A Business Overlay Zone. It also made multifamily housing a conditional use in District 4B, Office Area B. The ordinance lists these standards:
- Building types: duplex, quadruplex, townhouse or apartment
- Density: up to 14 units per acre
- Minimum lot area: 1 acre for townhouses, 3 acres for apartments
- Setbacks next to single-family homes: 30 feet on the side and 60 feet in the rear
- Coverage: 30 percent building coverage, 50 percent improved lot coverage
- Height: 28 feet and two-and-a-half stories
The Planning Board's summary adds that the mandatory affordable set-aside in District 3A goes from 15 to 20 percent for rental units, and that 4B housing carries a 20 percent set-aside as well.
That's townhouse-scale zoning.
The Planning Board said this wasn't in its own land use plan
The Planning Board's February 26, 2026 minutes show the borough planner presenting the ordinance as one of several measures "required of the Borough to comply with its New Jersey-mandated 4th round of affordable housing requirements." The board's attorney noted that 2026:1383 "is not consistent with the Borough's Land Use Plan Element because the Land Use Plan does not recommend multiple-family housing on either the Closter Commons site or in District 4B."
The board still voted 9-0 to recommend adoption. Its recommendation was conditioned on the governing body passing a resolution that lays out the reasons for adopting a zoning change that departs from the land use plan.
The rezoning meets a court-supervised obligation, and the borough's own long-range plan still doesn't recommend multifamily housing on these sites. The overlay gives property owners an option.
The Commons is 34 parcels, and the parcels have different owners
The Planning Board minutes describe Closter Commons as "34 contiguous parcels." The center sits at 570–600 Piermont Road. Parcel records list separate commercial units there, such as Unit B5 on Lot 3.15. Owner mailing addresses on those units include Fort Lauderdale, Edison, Teaneck and the center's own Piermont Road address. A Closter Commons Condominium Association, Inc. has been registered with the state since October 1988.
A shopping center held by one owner can be sold to a builder in one deal. A center split into condominium units held by multiple owners is a different problem. Under the ordinance, townhouses need at least one acre and apartments need three. Getting a contiguous site of that size out of a divided center raises the question of how to coordinate unit owners and their tenants. That's a coordination problem a zoning change alone can't solve.
The housing plan's own numbers show how far apart paper and pavement can be. It estimated about 7 acres at the Commons and 70 potential homes at 10 units per acre, before the adopted ordinance raised the ceiling to 14. It put the 4B office area at roughly 22 acres and 308 potential homes. As of this October, no owner or developer has publicly proposed housing on either site.
The housing that is actually getting built
One Closter project is moving. It's on Durie Avenue, not Piermont Road. Mastermind Development's Village School Commons turns the former Closter Village School at 511 Durie Avenue into 35 units of 100 percent affordable housing, with completion expected in 2027. NorthJersey.com reported in January that the plan reuses the old school building rather than tearing it down. On October 8, 2026, the Borough of Closter announced that applications were open.
These are income-restricted rentals, so they don't add homes to the for-sale market. One more site sits in the background: 515 Piermont Road, the Corner Farm. It got overlay zoning in Closter's Round 3 plan after negotiations with its owner. In May 2025, the owner sent the borough a letter asking to be considered for Round 4, but included no concept plans. That's another site zoned for housing years ago with no project yet.
What this means for an attached-home search in Closter
As of this October, no owner or developer has publicly proposed housing on either rezoned site. If you want new attached construction in the Northern Valley, judge each town by projects that have actually been filed or approved, not by what its zoning allows.
County numbers explain why the distinction matters. New Jersey REALTORS® doesn't publish a separate Closter report, but its September 2026 Bergen County update shows how differently the two property types are trading right now.
| Bergen County, September 2026 | Single-family | Townhouse-condo |
|---|---|---|
| Median sale price | $835,000 | $527,000 |
| Closed sales | 483 | 164 |
| Months of supply | 2.6 | 3.7 |
| Days on market until sale | 34 | 42 |
| Percent of list price received | 103.4% | 99.6% |
Across the county, attached homes sold for slightly under list price in September 2026, while single-family homes sold above it. In a town where attached homes are scarce and new supply is stuck at the zoning stage, the county average may not describe a particular Closter listing very well. That's especially true when the closest comparable sales are few and spread out over time.
This post is general information about local zoning, not legal or financial advice. Confirm how any ordinance affects a specific property with an attorney or the borough before you rely on it.
If you're weighing a Closter townhouse against attached options in other Northern Valley towns, I can pull the closed sales that actually compare to your target home. Christopher Falborn offers a free home valuation for owners who want to see where their Closter property stands before making their next move.